Three years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences for juveniles were unconstitutional, except for those found to be “irreparably corrupt” or “permanently incorrigible.”
On Jan. 25, it made that ruling retroactive, meaning Street, the Knox twins and more than 400 other lifers sentenced as juveniles in Pennsylvania—the highest number in the country—may be eligible for parole.
The majority of these inmates, more than 300, come from Philadelphia. Fifty, including the Knoxes and Street were sentenced in Allegheny County.
In its decision, however, the Supreme Court ruling did not include any procedural requirements, meaning it will be left to the state appellate courts to sort out when and in what order parole hearings are granted. But in some cases, the process to resentence these inmates is already underway.
Shortly after the 2012 Supreme Court ruling, the state Superior Court granted separate appeals to the Knox brothers and remanded their cases to Common Pleas Judge Donna Jo McDaniel for reconsideration. In October, she ordered Devon to serve 35 years to life. She resentenced Lovon to 25 years to life.
Jay Donaldson, who honors his son’s memory through the PROMISE group he founded to end neighborhood violence, and mentor and strengthen community youth, said the hearing was a tough experience.
“It wasn’t easy going though it again, but it was necessary. I got to read a letter from my other son, and tell them about PROMISE. I think they shouldn’t ever be let out, but 35 to life is a pretty damn good sentence,” he said. “I know some people will say some of these guys will be getting off the hook. But I say, at least I have some closure. There are families out there that never found their shooters.”
Beyond an inmate’s age, other sentencing considerations could include time incarcerated, conduct while in prison, criminal history, the nature of the homicide (first or second degree), was the juvenile the actual killer or an accomplice, etc.
For instance, after his arrest for Wallace’s murder, but prior to his conviction, Street and 25 other members of the Brighton Place Crips were convicted on federal racketeering charges.
And because all of these crimes left victims, their families will have the right to appear at any hearings and oppose parole or potential release.
Jennifer Storm, spokesperson for the Pennsylvania Office of the Victim Advocate said in a Jan. 25 email that her office was informing victims’ families of the high court ruling.
“OVA has been continuously updating our affected victims, who include families and loved ones of those murdered in Pennsylvania,” she said. “We are currently working hard to inform and empower our victims about today’s ruling and will ensure their voices are heard during any possible parole considerations that may result from today’s decision.”
In a related action just one day after the court ruling, President Barack Obama issued an executive order limiting the time juveniles in the federal penitentiary system may be kept in solitary confinement, saying the practice is overused and has the potential for devastating psychological consequences.
“How can we subject prisoners to unnecessary solitary confinement, knowing its effects, and then expect them to return to our communities as whole people?”
This eliminates the punitive use of isolation for all “low-level” non-violent crimes, and reduces the number of consecutive days one can be held in isolation to 60, from 365. Acknowledging that because juveniles, and some adults fear for their safety, will intentionally commit offense so they can be put in isolation. The administration’s guidelines say such isolation should be the “least restrictive setting necessary.”
Like us at https://www.facebook.com/pages/New-Pittsburgh-Courier/143866755628836?ref=hl
Follow @NewPghCourier on Twitter https://twitter.com/NewPghCourier
Download our mobile app at https://www.appshopper.com/news/new-pittsburgh-courier