
Bill Cosby cannot get a fair trial anywhere in these United States. Alleged victims, their lawyers and now Pennsylvania prosecutors, have made that impossible by their out of court statements.
The Canons of Professional Responsibility prohibit attorneys such as Gloria Allred , the legal counsel for twenty nine women making claims against Cosby, from making extra judicial remarks which have a “substantial likelihood of prejudicing the trier of facts.”
Allred and her clients have baited Cosby and his lawyers into making denials which they now claim are defamatory. Allred’s approach to defamation is unprecedented in that denials are not defamatory whereas Cosby has viable counterclaims against all of these women who have baited him into making denials.
Impugning someone in their trade and profession which these women have done is defamation per se. Their only defense will be truth and each of them will be judged individually where they will be subject to cross examination regarding their delays in reporting.
In their cases, they must prove that his denials are defamation and that they have actual damages which are not self-imposed. They should lose as a matter of law.
Their claims are barred by a civil Statute of Limitations of (1) year for tort claims such as assault and battery. Most jurisdictions in the United States also limit the criminal law Statute of Limitations to under ten (10) years in cases of alleged sexual abuse. Pennsylvania’s laws are an anomaly.
The so-called victim in Pennsylvania settled the case there under seal ten years ago. A Pennsylvania prosecutor declined prosecution at that time but what has now changed is that the complainant who settled her case for an undisclosed sum and signed a release to that effect is joining with others to revive a criminal prosecution which was closed long ago.
A civil record was unsealed where Mr. Cosby made admissions which he soon denied saying that he misunderstood the question. Yet, lawyers are aware that transcripts of examinations before trial must be signed by the parties before a notary and they are subject to errata corrections by the deponent, in this case Mr. Cosby.
When Mr. Cosby settled his civil case he did so without an admission of wrongdoing on his part. Therefore, this new evidence which the prosecutors rely upon is not new at all.
The Pennsylvania alleged victim has violated the terms of the sealing order and as such is liable to Cosby for damages and the return of any settlement monies paid to her. Incidentally, the women who went to the Playboy mansion, what did they think was going to happen there? And for those who met with Mr. Cosby alone, were they also naïve or interested in having sex with an African American celebrity?
As for Ms. Allred, we appeared on the Montel Williams show together with opposing views. She at the time was representing Miss Universe against the Sultan of Brunei. In a semi-circle between us were several underage, pregnant young women and their mothers alleging that two African American defendants in Pensacola, Florida had statutorily raped them together with approximately two hundred other young women. The women and the two defendants submitted to DNA testing on the air which was paid for by the Williams’ show. The results were negative. At the time I said to Ms. Allred on the air: “Gloria, it’s all about money isn’t it?” In the Cosby case, it is still all about money.
____________________
*Thomas F. Liotti is an attorney and Village Justice. He is a Past Chair of the New York State Bar Association’s Criminal Justice Section and Editor of its Journal. He is an Adjunct Professor at Nassau Community College
Thomas F. Liotti, Esq.
Garden City, NY