
After years of demanding the city of Pittsburgh and its related authorities comply with the strictures of the Hill Community Benefits Agreement which they signed in relation to development of the former civic arena site, the Hill Consensus Group is trying a new strategy: have the feds compel compliance.
On Dec. 2, the Consensus Group filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development charging the City of Pittsburgh, its Planning Commission, the Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority and the Sports and Entertainment Authority of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County with racial discrimination for disproportionately excluding African Americans from the housing planned for the site.
The complaint notes the Community Collaboration Implementation Plan, a deal agreed to last year by the named respondents and Hill political leaders—but not the Consensus Group, set the affordable housing level at 20 percent, 15 percent for residents making less than 80 percent of the median area income and 5 percent for those making less than 70 percent.
At those levels, the complaint charges, “the vast majority of African American city and Hill District residents, unlike White Hill District and city residents, would not be able to occupy a single unit in this development.”
Eighty percent of the area median income is $39,100. That is almost twice the median household income for Blacks in Pittsburgh: $20,946.
Because of that, Consensus Group attorney Don Driscoll notes in the complaint that respondents may have violated three distinct components of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 and 1964:
•Denying or making unavailable dwellings on the basis of race;
•Failing to affirmatively further fair housing; and
•excluding participation in a program or activity supported by federal funds on the basis of race.
“It excludes very low income people,” said Driscoll. “It excludes most black families in the city. It excludes all voucher holders.”
Tim McNulty, spokesman for Mayor Bill Peduto, said the city has no problem with HUD looking at the development plan.
“We welcome a HUD review of the Lower Hill Development, our commitments to affordable housing, and our efforts toward reversing decades of disinvestment in Hill District neighborhoods,” he said.
“The CCIP resulted from historic collaboration among all stakeholders to establish minimum standards of commitments to affordable housing and neighborhood inclusion within the development, and we have made significant investments in a neighborhood-wide housing study to maximize opportunities for housing in the Hill District. That work will be aided by the efforts of the Affordable Housing Task Force, which will be studying housing offerings in high-opportunity areas citywide.”
Because some HUD monies, Community Development Block Grants, and HOME program funds have already been expended on the project, along with U.S. Department of transportation funding, and because the agency has jurisdiction over housing discrimination.
The department would only confirm the complaint had been received and is under review.
Like us at https://www.facebook.com/pages/New-Pittsburgh-Courier/143866755628836?ref=hl
Follow @NewPghCourier on Twitter https://twitter.com/NewPghCourier
Download our mobile app at https://www.appshopper.com/news/new-pittsburgh-courier