New Pittsburgh Courier

#BlackLivesMatter to Who?

PoliceChokeholdDeath2
Demonstrators with a placard declaring that ‘Black Lives Matter’ during a demonstration in New York yesterday to protest the death of Eric Garner. (AP Photo/File)

#BlackLivesMatter. That’s a trending mantra on Twitter.
Black Lives Matter. Those are the signs held by protesters and t-shirts worn in cities across the country displaying concerns about police brutality and social injustice in the aftermath of police killing two unarmed black men: Michael Brown in Ferguson, MO and Eric Garner in New York City.
Black Lives Matter. That’s the recent findings of the Justice Department that cited the Cleveland Police Department for a pattern of “unreasonable and unnecessary use of force” in a report filed after a two-year investigation. The City of Cleveland is working on a settlement with the Justice Department, consenting to an array of internal strategies designed to overhaul the department’s current protocols. Those changes came too late to save 12-year-old Tamir Rice, a Black youth shot dead by a rookie police officer within two seconds of his arrival on the scene. Tamir had a toy gun.
Mike Green

Overall, however, Black lives don’t matter to many Americans, Black and White. There’s a lot of room to disagree on this issue, but there’s also significant room for alignment and progress, if we focus on the underlying issue the nation has been struggling with since it was founded. It is that premise that serves as the foundation of my new ebook, “From Freedom to Ferguson: The Private Sector Opportunity to Empower Black America.”If you think you fully grasp the anguish behind the outcry #BlackLivesMatter, I urge you to read on. And if you want to know even more beyond this posting, please purchase my book. Your support of my work will enable me to do much more of it. And if there’s anything we need today is more efforts focused on solutions. But to get to a platform of solutions, we must be willing to fully grasp (and agree) how we got to this point in time. My book starts at the “schizophrenic” founding of America, as Dr. King described it. But in this posting, let’s connect with the aftermath of the Civil War and see what happened to Black people over the following 15 decades.
From 1865-1951: The Library of Congress chronicles numerous White mob riots and nearly 4,000 Blacks lynched (conservative figures; larger numbers are recorded by media). Leading lynching states: Mississippi, Georgia, Texas, Louisiana and Alabama. And with the exception of four states (Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Hampshire and Vermont), lynching of Blacks occurred in all states in the continental U.S.
Imagine being a Black family in an era of institutionalized terrorism. Imagine not knowing whether your father or husband would return home from whatever meager subsistence he could find to feed his family. Imagine being a Black man … the most feared member of society. Imagine being told if you just work hard, keep your nose clean and follow the rules, you can succeed in America. Imagine that advice ringing in your ears as you hear the news that another member of your community didn’t make it home last night. Or there was another church bombing. Or 35 blocks of Black businesses were burned to the ground. Or your family is being told they will have to leave, now, along with 6,000 others.
In my book, I provide a timeline of events chronicled by the Library of Congress. But, for many White Americans, the shared experiences of Black Americans may seem far-fetched or just a figment of our imagination. After all, if what is being said is true, that would mean millions of White people were conspiring against Black people. It would mean the credibility and integrity of people you know, love and trust is at risk. It would potentially mean ripping apart the paradigm that has been carefully constructed to represent what you’ve come to believe America is all about. There must be some other explanation for the Black experience other than Whites established a land of hostility and systemic aggression against Blacks for generations leading up to the present day. That cannot be the case. Right?
Focus on (blaming) the Family
For those who point to Black America today and argue that fatherless homes and out-of-wedlock births foster economic distress, I will have to agree. Individuals must own responsibility for their decisions and actions. But then I would ask critics of the Black family to also address the institutionalized White power structure, including both the public and private sectors that quarantined, segregated, economically undermined and terrorized Black people. Do the private sector leaders, stakeholders and influencers own any responsibility as well? If so, what has the private sector done that is in their power to do to change the economic circumstances of a people who emerged destitute from slavery?
As for individual responsibility … even as late as 1950, Black America had a 17% out-of-wedlock birth rate. Indeed, that was high for the 1950s. But, surely we can all agree that a mere 17% rate of out-of-wedlock births after nearly a century of being targeted, terrorized and brutalized by a society that hated us, was remarkably resilient! Black America was surprisingly intact, albeit poor. Yes, poor. And there was no question that Black America was under economic duress due specifically to systemic hostility coursing through the veins of the private sector and spilling over into public political battles. So, at what point did White America switch to blaming Black America for her woes? Read on.
Black lives didn’t matter in the Antebellum Era nor the Reconstruction Period nor during Jim Crow.
The 100 years following the Civil War, leading up to and through the Civil Rights Movement, was marked by societal-sanctioned domestic terrorism targeting Black families across the nation, which instilled fear in families that persists to this day.
The challenge for many White Americans to fully understand the outcries from Black Americans today is, in part, the widespread amnesia that afflicts America. My parents, uncles and aunts were born in the 30s and 40s and had children in the 50s and 60s, including me. My dad and some others from his generation are still alive today. They lived through an era of institutionalized White aggression and tyranny impacting Black Americans from all walks of life. It was Whites who prohibited Whites from marrying Blacks. And it was Whites who owned all the means of production, finance, investments, real estate development, government contracting, etc. In every aspect of life, Blacks were subjected to the rules and/or whims of Whites. Baby Boomer Black Americans, and those older, have not only remembered this era of national fear they felt, alongside severely limited opportunities available in the Land of the Free, but the primary change they witnessed was the acceleration of the destruction of the Black family. They watched things get worse for the collective Black America, even as some individuals were beginning to find pathways to relative success.
Black data matter.
Amazingly, the Black family was relatively intact from the end of the Civil War until the Civil Rights Movement had begun. Then, for some unexplained reason the out-of-wedlock birth rate in Black America skyrocketed from 17% in 1951 to 62% in 1987. And White America wagged a hypocritical finger of disappointment at Black America for a 45% rise in out-of-wedlock births in 36 years.
Interestingly, no one ever asked the question of why would Black America maintain a relatively low 17% out-of-wedlock birth rate for more than eight decades following the Civil War, and suddenly in a span of less than four decades, experience more than double the rate of out-of-wedlock births? How did that happen? Did any sociologist, historian, economist, research institute or elected leader anywhere in America think (or care) to ask?

Black History Matters.
While White America’s public and private sector power brokers and influencers created a caustic and chaotic fear-filled landscape for generations of Black families for more than 100 years, many of those same folks and their families are privileged to fondly remember the era as one to which they seek to return the nation. It would almost be a laughable notion were they not extremely serious about it.
I’d like to ask corporate CEOs and conservative political leaders to consider what evidence is there today that proves Black lives actually do matter in the private sector and legislative bodies, both state and federal? The outcry over the killing of unarmed Black men isn’t new. There’s been a steady chorus of outcries for 150 years!
Moreover, many of the private sector mobs, organized groups and business owners who practiced routine aggression and bias against Black Americans are part of the Baby Boomer generation, born from America’s “Greatest Generation” that also practiced aggression against Black people and routinely dismissed Black voices crying out against violence, institutional bias, social injustice and economic Apartheid leading up to the struggle for Civil Rights in the 50s and 60s. That same dismissive attitude continues today.
Racism Doesn’t Matter … Say Some Whites
If we believe the perspectives of many White Americans, no one is racist or responsible for the plight of Black America other than Black Americans themselves. And if we would just stop the cacophony of racism noise, the problems of the past would become ghosts of the dead and eventually distant memories of a bygone era.
Ironically, that’s an understandable perspective. The nation is still struggling today with the same unbroken string of struggles and aggression perpetrated against Black Americans from Reconstruction. And in the midst of each era of blatant racism and overt hostilities resulting in the deaths of Black people, there were always isolated white people with good hearts who couldn’t imagine the horrors they heard. Obviously, those must’ve been isolated incidents! In the past, no social media existed to deliver a daily diet of very consistent episodes of White power perpetrated upon the powerless. So, it is understandable for those growing up in the Ozzie and Harriett, Leave It To Beaver, Andy Griffith’s Mayberry white Utopia universe that any hint of a nationally sanctioned stranglehold on Black people would sound absurd.
Black lives matter … but not to many during the struggle for Civil Rights.
In 1963, a Gallup Poll revealed 50 percent of White Americans believed President John F. Kennedy was pushing too hard on integrating Blacks. When journalists asked about his views regarding the poll results, JFK continued to assert his support for integration efforts. Two months later he was assassinated. Whether his assassination was racially motivated or not, the fact remains that he disagreed with a widespread sentiment among Whites who devalued Black lives, and in the end his life also didn’t matter to some folk.
In 1965, Malcolm X was a strong influence in helping Black people face fears that had become embedded within Black communities. He was determined to overcome institutionalized second-class U.S. citizenship “by any means necessary.” He was assassinated. His life didn’t matter to some folk.
.
In 1965, the now-infamous Moynihan Report (officially titled, “The Negro Family: The Case for National Action”) concluded that Black Americans had, indeed, been the target of institutionalized discrimination, social terrorism and economic Apartheid for 100 years following the Civil War. This report was prepared by the Department of Labor and contained commentary from Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who concluded this trend of White aggression would continue for generations unless a national crisis effort was established to disrupt the caustic chaos that resulted in deterioration of the Black family core.
.
.The government report cited rising rates of out-of-wedlock births, fatherless homes, severe education achievement gaps and crime-ridden communities as a result of the nation’s ongoing aggression against Black people. The response by the White male-dominated public and private sectors was to blame Black people for their own economic distress and point to the data on the deterioration of the Black family core as the cause of the economic distress (rather than a result of it), thus absolving White America of any responsibility and acquitting itself, acting as both jury and judge.
Black lives didn’t matter individually or collectively to the White public and private sectors across the nation in 1965. In the aftermath of the Moynihan Report, no national crisis intervention was enacted. And no state enacted its own institutional public-private partnership effort of economic competitiveness to empower Black Americans. To this day, no region has a Comprehensive Economic Development Strategies (CEDS) plan for empowering Black communities.
In 1968, Dr. Martin Luther King was killed, just three years after he voiced his iconic “dream.” Today, many across America pay homage to Dr. King and his extraordinary contribution toward pricking the conscience of White America. But his life obviously didn’t matter to some folk.
Black lives don’t matter … no matter how intelligent, famous and beloved.
In 1976, the then-famous Quayle Poll surveyed White voters, both Republicans and Democrats, in Illinois during the race between Spiro Agnew and Edward Kennedy to determine their views on race. At least 65 percent of all Whites on both sides of the political aisle said the government had “gone far enough” or “gone too far” in helping Blacks. For a large majority of White voters in Illinois, which was echoed across America, Black lives didn’t matter. In their view, the government had already gone too far. And the private sector whistled a tune of absolution for its past, present and ongoing sins against Black America.
Soon thereafter, Ronald Reagan reminded White Americans they were the good guys and America was a great nation, where if you worked hard and kept your nose clean, you could succeed regardless of your circumstances. Reagan was a turning point in America from a nation of White people who struggled with the question of what should be done with Black people (see Moynihan report) to a nation who simply dismissed the question altogether. “Let them fend for themselves” became the prominent protocol.
Suddenly, White America, in particular many public and private sector leaders and influencers, were stricken with amnesia that enabled them to breathe a collective sigh of relief. The majority of America’s White elite were satisfied that they no longer had to grapple with guilt over the never-ending economic distress, social injustices and institutionalized discrimination they had fostered and sustained within Black communities and generations of Black families.
Black lives don’t matter … no matter how young or how old.
The attitudes of blaming Black folk for their own ills resonated with millions of White Americans across the nation. And the private sector, which gleefully boasted responsibility for job growth, wealth creation and America’s global economic competitiveness, ignored any responsibility for its failure to invest in uplifting the economic competitiveness of Black communities at any point in the past 150 years.
Today, America’s Black communities remain uniformly disconnected from their local innovation and economic job-producing ecosystems. Black-owned businesses collectively produce less than 1 percent of GDP and zero percent job growth. And they have no power among themselves to change those circumstances. That power belongs to the private sector. Unfortunately, to the private sector, these communities and businesses didn’t matter then and most don’t matter now. And the people within them didn’t matter. To the private sector, America is a meritocratic democratic nation of economic opportunity for all; her meritocratic environment of opportunity is the reason why our shores are flooded with immigrants seeking to live here.
Black lives don’t matter … even in protest.
To the private sector, the protests, marches, signs and t-shirts remind them of that awful period in America’s history when somebody else was doing unimaginable harm to Black people. No one seems to know who was being aggressive toward Black people. And few believe it was anywhere as bad for Black people as they tend to pronounce.
And in any case, the struggles of that era were all settled after Dr. King’s great speech in 1963 in the minds of many White Americans. And any debt of any kind most assuredly was all settled after the 1964 Civil Rights Act. And then there was the 1965 Voting Rights Act. So, what else is left for White people to do for Black people? In the minds of many, those acts had gone far enough or perhaps even too far! Black people should now pull themselves up by their own bootstraps and dive into the rugged individualism of the greatest nation in the world! Right?
Black lives don’t matter … when they clash with institutions of White power.
To many White Americans, Black lives don’t matter. And no amount of signage or slogans on a t-shirt or trending twitter discussion will have any influence or affect such a privileged paradigm. Many of those harboring such dismissive attitudes are those same folks for whom Black lives didn’t matter 50 years ago. Not much has changed.
And a few protests and marches won’t change anything either, especially when they are marred by opportunists to whom private sector protagonists can point and say, “see”? And turn off the television.

Black lives matter.
But there is hope. Change has occurred. And I’m not referring to the election of a Black president, although that was a monumental moment in American history. The real change is economic. And that is where the crux of the matter has always been. In a capitalist society, justice of any kind swings on the hinges of economic power.
Today, the private sector is starting to listen to the argument being made that it has a stake in the matter of social injustice and owns a large part of the responsibility for the economic empowerment of Black America. Not because it is the right thing to do. Not because it is reparations or restoration for wrongdoings over the past 150 years leading up to the present day. None of those rational reasons would penetrate the absolution offered by Reagan and the paradigm of progress he presented as a national vision devoid of significant contribution by underrepresented populations.
Black lives matter … to the economic competitiveness of the United States.
The winning argument is in fact that the population of the U.S. will, by mid-century, be comprised of 42 percent Black and Hispanic Americans. With so much of the population producing so little, our paltry collective contribution to the GDP and anemic job growth will inadvertently place America’s strong global economic competitiveness ranking at risk. And with such a rapidly growing underserved population of Americans, the economic competitiveness and wealth of the entire nation will be at stake. That’s “their” wealth. The problem and the power to enact a solution is theirs also.
But “we” must have a vision, strategy and plan of action, too. We cannot reasonably expect economic progress by relying upon incessant outcries over what we don’t have and the resources we lack. We must begin to articulate the enormous value inherent in what we do have. Are we collecting data and producing information reports? Are journalists covering the stories of success that permeate every nook and cranny of Black America? We must tell our own stories and identify the value in our communities that can attract investment. After all, White Americans are privileged to live in isolation and ignorance of who we are and the history we live. We must raise our voices, for sure. But we must raise them with vision, strategy and purpose that results in measurable outcomes.
Our vision must not seek to isolate and disconnect us from the vast resources of the nation at large. We must join with the private sector’s existing frameworks and provide strategic approaches toward bridging disconnected populations to existing innovation ecosystems. We must work collaboratively with America’s private sector to empower Black America’s enormous reservoir of workforce and entrepreneurial talent. We must provide a pathway of progress that includes access for anyone and everyone who chooses to enter the economic competitiveness arena. We must develop and expand an Inclusive Competitiveness infrastructure nationwide, responding to Moynihan’s clarion call.
Black lives do matter … equally to White lives.
And when we begin to speak the language of the 21st century innovation economy, and appeal to the private sector’s core concerns of Inclusive Capitalism, we will find that all lives actually do matter to them. In particular those lives that contribute to the health, wealth and competitiveness of America’s knowledge-based, tech-driven, globally competitive Innovation Economy.
Moynihan posed a choice for the nation that still rings true today: “America is free to choose whether the Negro will remain her liability or become her opportunity.”
Well, we know first of all that White “America” regarded “the Negro” as a “liability” in 1965 and all decades prior. And we know from poll after poll, during every election cycle over the last 50 years that White America’s sentiment toward Black people has not changed (notwithstanding individual White Americans who do not adhere to such ideology). Today, the private sector still regards Black people as a “liability.”
Black lives matter … to the future success of America.
It is up to us (Black Americans) to show the vision and value we have long brought to this nation. That is our opportunity. We must show the nation that Black lives do matter.
We can start now by hosting solutions-oriented #BlackLivesMatter Town Halls and Summits. We have a great opportunity to produce 100 #BlackLivesMatter Town Halls in 100 cities nationwide during the months of January and February 2015. From Dr. King’s birthday through Black History Month and the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Voting Rights Act, this is a window of opportunity to discuss a national vision to invest in the economic competitiveness of Black America and capitalize upon the enormous amount of talent that exists today in economically distressed communities across America.
America, it’s time to choose. Will Black lives remain your liability or become your opportunity? I hope to be invited to speak at your #BlackLivesMatter Town Hall.
Mike Green is an award-winning journalist, national speaker and co-founder of ScaleUp Partners LLC. He is also the author of “From Freedom to Ferguson: The Private Sector Opportunity to Empower Black America.” Mike can be reached at mike@scaleuppartners.com. Follow him on Twitter at @amikegreen2.”
Exit mobile version